Student Voice: Carnegie’s Reaction to #YesAllWomen

Shortly after the tragedy of the Isla Vista shootings, the hashtag #YesAllWomen began trending on Twitter, spurring nation-wide debates on the growing culture of violence against women. Carnegie students have been active in such debates, one of which was initiated by Abby Govindan ’15:

6 people will not go home to their families just because a male teenage student [Elliot Rodger] felt entitled to sex and felt entirely justified in taking lives because he doesn’t have a girlfriend.
Tell me again why we don’t need feminism.

Govindan’s classmates quickly joined the debate. Camille Hollan, ’15, argued that the support received by Rodger “is indicative of a much larger cultural problem.” Samantha Nadel, ’15, lamented the trend of “women [being] punished for making choices over their own bodies.”

Not all of Govindan’s peers concurred with her argument, however. One felt that feminism “has been trivialized as a movement” because of “[those] feminists who don’t fight for equality, but…seek superiority over men.” Maddie Davet, ’16, delivered an argument similar to Govindan’s, stating that feminism resulted from the “same idea” as the Civil Rights Movement, but has a “different name.” Janadhi Seneviratne was inspired to write her own account of why feminism is important to her; it is printed below.

Lately, #YesToAllWomen has been trending on social networks, encouraging women and men of all races and ages to talk about their experiences and views on feminism. While some are more encouraging than others, through the recent trend, women have been able to come together and talk about everyday sexism, shown in the most mundane ways. One might question how a seemingly ordinary teenager could experience sexism, but even the littlest things can add up. Growing up, I knew from my parents that my job was always to clean and cook, but I knew from a young age that it wasn’t fair. I always cried or had a hissy fit if my brother didn’t do anything, or if he got to cut the lawn and I didn’t. It was one those things that always irked me, but I kept living on with my life with my parents telling me the dangers of the world. Though I knew that there were many dangers, I wasn’t really aware about how bad those dangers could be. Only recently have I been aware about what has been going on and why, and to be honest, it is quite annoying that I can’t walk down the street without having a man stare at me weirdly or call me something weird. I always hated covering up instead of choosing something comfortable to wear in the hot summer days. The few times I have been caught for wearing something “short” was by male teachers, and that really annoys me, that I have to tailor myself so some guy won’t be distracted from his work rather than wear something that is comfortable for me. Though my parents have done everything in their ability to shelter me from the harsh things that go around the world, they don’t realize that, even going into school, I still deal with sexism. Guys will wear shirts saying things like, “Cool story, babe, now make me a sandwich,” or say the rudest things without being aware of how rude those things are. I think the worst part is that most girls are told not to get raped by boys, as opposed to telling boys not to rape girls (though that’s what I heard or seen). Though I know this world is imperfect, I hope by the time I have my own children, we will have true egalitarianism. 

Janadhi Seneviratne, ’16

Related News

  • I believe this discussion would require a lot of uncomfortable honesty from both sides, but it’s an important discussion to have.

    A whlie back I hypothesized that sexism dates back to Genesis in many of the Old Testament scriptures. Which bible one reads there may be some differences. From the “Holy Bible” (NIV) Chapter 3, verse 16

    To the woman he said,
    “I will greatly increase your pains in
    with pain you will give birth to children.
    Your desire will be for your husband,
    and he will rule over you.”

    So from this I interpret that sexism and male chauvenism dates back to the origin of the human race. I personally don’t accept the Bible–any Bible–as literal truth or as a canon account of historical events. I would assume that it was written primarily by men and tribal leaders. I’m not a theologian, biblical scholar, nor a history major, so I emphasize my statements are OPINIONS.

    I believe feminism/equal rights for women is a natural evolution of ideas, and that it’s important for it to become a reality. How that would be achieved though I can’t begin to suggest.

    One of my favorite musicians, philosophers, peace and social activists wrote a song that was released in 1972; his name was John Lennon, who happened to be married to a woman, Yoko Ono.

    I’m censoring one of the words because it’s one I don’t like to use. Although some people don’t find it offensive, I think there are much better and more accurate adjectives and pronouns to use in its place.

    If anyone is interested in how this song was received and any repercussions that it caused, there is a Wikipedia page about it, as well as other reference material if one doesn’t approve of Wikipedia.

    “Woman Is The N*g*r Of The World”

    Woman is the n*g*r of the world
    Yes she is…think about it
    Woman is the n*g*r of the world
    Think about it…do something about it

    We make her paint her face and dance
    If she won’t be slave, we say that she don’t love us
    If she’s real, we say she’s trying to be a man
    While putting her down we pretend that she is above us
    Woman is the n*g*r of the world…yes she is
    If you don’t belive me take a look to the one you’re with
    Woman is the slaves of the slaves
    Ah yeah…better scream about it
    We make her bear and raise our children
    And then we leave her flat for being a fat old mother hen
    We tell her home is the only place she would be
    Then we complain that she’s too unworldly to be our friend
    Woman is the n*g*r of the world…yes she is
    If you don’t believe me take a look to the one you’re with
    Woman is the slaves of the slaves
    Yeah (think about it)

    We insult her everyday on TV
    And wonder why she has no guts or confidence
    When she’s young we kill her will to be free
    While telling her not to be so smart we put her down for being so dumb
    Woman is the n*g*r of the world…yes she is
    If you don’t belive me take a look to the one you’re with
    Woman is the slaves of the slaves
    Yes she is…if you believe me, you better scream about it.

    We make her paint her face and dance
    We make her paint her face and dance
    We make her paint her face and dance

Who We Are
Rhino Press is Houston’s largest interscholastic news organization. Launched in 2014, Rhino Press expanded from a campus newspaper to a global network of 150 high school journalists, editors, photographers, social media interns, and board members and 20,000 student readers. Today, the online platform aims to give a voice to the millennial generation and combine cutting-edge content with social media.